Search

Search form

New Jersey Ban on 'Currently Employed' Requirement in Job Ads Resists Constitutional Challenge

  • January 14, 2014

A New Jersey appeals court has upheld a state law banning employers from stating in job advertisements that applicants “must be currently employed,” ruling the law does not infringe upon the constitutional right to “free speech.” New Jersey Dep’t of Labor and Workforce Dev. v. Crest Ultrasonics et al., No. A-0417-12T4 (N.J. App. Div. Jan. 7, 2014).

In 2011, the New Jersey legislature passed N.J.S.A. § 34:8B-1, which, in relevant part, prohibits an employer seeking to fill a position in New Jersey from making any statement in an advertisement that only currently employed applicants will be considered for the position. In short, New Jersey banned a “must be currently employed” qualification from job advertisements. (For more on the law, see our article, New Jersey Passes Law Prohibiting Exclusion of Unemployed Individuals for Job Vacancies.)

Facts

Following the departure of a manager with over 20 years of experience, Crest Ultrasonics, a manufacturer and distributor of ultrasonic cleaning equipment, sought a replacement with “current and up to date” technical knowledge of the position. Its advertisement of the job vacancy stated that applicants “must be currently employed,” among other qualifications.

A reader of the advertisement complained to the New Jersey Department of Labor and Workforce Development (“NJDLWD”). Following an investigation, the NJDLWD issued the employer a notice of violation and a $1,000 fine. 

The employer challenged the violation on the grounds that the law unlawfully infringed upon its constitutional rights to free speech under both the First Amendment to the U.S. Constitution and Article I, Paragraph 6 of the New Jersey State Constitution. 

Ad is Commercial Speech

The New Jersey Appellate Division held an employment advertisement is a form of commercial speech. Therefore, restrictions on it are subject to a less-stringent level of judicial scrutiny than restrictions placed upon political speech

The court concluded the law and its restrictions on commercial speech are narrowly tailored to directly advance a substantial governmental interest and, therefore, passed constitutional muster. It ruled the content-based restrictions advanced the substantial governmental interest to increase opportunities for the unemployed. The court explained the effects of the recession, swelling unemployment rolls, and the legitimate objective of returning individuals to the ranks of the employed supported the substantial government interest necessary for the statute to withstand scrutiny.

The court further held the restrictions are narrowly tailored and, in fact, do not require an employer to read such applications or interview or hire unemployed applicants. Instead, it ruled the law simply prohibits an employer from expressly stating that only currently employed applicants will be considered for employment in an advertisement. It noted Oregon, New York City, and the District of Columbia enacted similar (and in some instances more expansive) protections for unemployed job-seekers.

Following a conservative constitutional analysis, the court upheld the legislative enactment.

***

Employers seeking to fill positions in New Jersey should consider reviewing their job advertisement protocols to ensure compliance with the law. 

Please contact the Jackson Lewis attorney with whom you regularly work if you have any questions.

©2020 Jackson Lewis P.C. This material is provided for informational purposes only. It is not intended to constitute legal advice nor does it create a client-lawyer relationship between Jackson Lewis and any recipient. Recipients should consult with counsel before taking any actions based on the information contained within this material. This material may be considered attorney advertising in some jurisdictions. Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome.

Focused on labor and employment law since 1958, Jackson Lewis P.C.'s 950+ attorneys located in major cities nationwide consistently identify and respond to new ways workplace law intersects business. We help employers develop proactive strategies, strong policies and business-oriented solutions to cultivate high-functioning workforces that are engaged, stable and diverse, and share our clients' goals to emphasize inclusivity and respect for the contribution of every employee. For more information, visit https://www.jacksonlewis.com.